Thursday, October 17, 2013

Comparing Plans--More Horrible Interface Design

It's been a few days since I posted. It was more fun keeping up on the government shutdown than comparing plans. And since I got to the point where I have to choose, I figured some of the pressure was off.

Last night as I was watching the final passage of the final deals, I logged into healthcare.gov again. I was able to log in but not able to continue my application. This morning I tried again and got in without any issues.

So, for the first time I decided to use the little Compare check box. You can see it checked in the picture below.

It seems like it would be a nice feature. You scroll through the long list of similarly named plans with small but significant differences. And you see one you'd like. So you click Compare.

Seems useful, right? I mean, that's why there's a list of dozens of plans--to compare the differences, right.

But, what should be a useful feature is made super annoying by this:

Yes, the designers of this page, in their infinite wisdom, decided that the user needs to be told that the plan whose Compare check box I just checked has been added to my compare list. I just added it, I don't need you to tell me--just show the check mark in the check box! But, that's not why this design decision is so horrible. No. If all it did was tell I did what I just asked it to do, that would be annoying, but not enough to get me to write a post about it. No, it does something worse.

The designers of this page decided that the best way to notify me that I did what I just did is to scroll to the top of the screen to the navigation bar to put the notification on the navigation bar! Hey, why not just go through the stack of books on my nightstand and slip all the book marks, while you're at it? Ugh! Now I have to go through that whole list again--the list of similarly named plans with small differences that might be significant. Yeah, make me lose my place each time I want to add a plan to the compare list because some moron knows nothing about UI design.

Grrr...

Anyway, if you click the compare region at the top, you get this screen:

I have 4 plans that I chose to compare for this preliminary comparison. I'll add more later. I have a big enough screen that I can certainly see more than 3 if the site is willing to show me more than 3. But, it looks like 3 is the limit.

Friday, October 11, 2013

Enrollment To Do List: A Case Study in Awful Page Design

This is the page you'll get to some time after your eligibility is done. Behold it in its glorious horror.

I mentioned the issue with the page in a previous post, but this post will focus on this page.

First, there is an orange bar telling me I have some outstanding issue. It provides a link. Here is the page that appears when I click that link:

I redacted some gobblety-gook just in case it contains information that might allow a hacker to get into my account. I left enough to show how ugly it is, though.

So, back the the Enroll To Do list.

There are 4 steps. You can see that I completed the first step because it has a check and a button that would allow me to change my answers. All this step did for me was ask if I smoke.

The last 2 steps are locked because you can only work on one step at a time.

My complaint with this screen is how you perform the next step. On most of the web site, the mouse pointer is the little arrow. When you mouse over a button, like the button shown which says "CHANGE", the mouse pointer turns into a little hand with an extended index finger. It also turns into the hand with the index finger when you mouse over a clickable link, such as the Application Details link or the Explain this task links shown above.

Now, on the right of the step, there is a green area with the word SET. When you mouse over SET, it just turns into the cursor which would appear if you wanted to select text for copying. It's just the plain arrow in the green area. Nothing indicates that this is an area where you can click to make something happen.

But, that's exactly what it is. It's a clickable area. It's not a button. It's not a link. And the word "SET" is near meaningless.

This is just one poorly designed page. What I wouldn't give to be a fly on the wall in the cubicle of the designer trying to explain this design to their peers and superiors.

Window Shopping Now Available

According to TPM.com, you can now Window shop. Way to add a feature just after I'm done needing it, HHS!

But, seriously, this is a good thing. I definitely want to window shop on plans in Washington state since I intend to move there. If you can't shop without creating an account and your account has to be for the state in which you need insurance, that made it hard to see what's out there for states where you want insurance.

So, it's not exactly too little, too late, but it would have nice a week ago. And it's a step I applaud.

Thursday, October 10, 2013

I'm Eligible. Now What?

I did all the applying in a separate Chrome window. I remember a button about continuing to enrollment. But when I went back to my other window and logged into the account, I had no clue how to get that button again. The application is listed as in progress. There is a link to download the eligibility PDF. But there was nothing that showed me what to do to shop for insurance.

Fortunately, the tab with the Continue to Enrollment button was still open. I had that Session Expiring dialog and I'm not sure if my session was expired. I had to blast through a few error messages, but got to the point here it showed me some steps. I told it I don't smoke.

I should have taken a screen shot. There are no buttons, but there are green areas with the word "SET" in if you click in that area, you activate the step. I don't what universe the designer of this screen came from. But oh well.

So now I'm to the plan page. It says I have 0 plans to choose from. Time to call it a night.


The Modal Dialog From Hell

Some modal dialog boxes are horrible. I don't know if this one is from Chrome or from healthcare.gov. Either way, it's bad.

If you don't know what a modal dialog box is, it's a dialog box that you have to deal with before you can continue using an applications. There a lot of them. The Open and Save dialog boxes are usually modal. They require you to find or name a file before they let you continue with the application you are using.

A web session is a way of connecting stuff you do on the internet when you do them close together in time. Web pages are stateless, so a web session allows pages to store data for later pages to use. On the healthcare.gov site, once you have logged in, a session is started. After a half hour, the session starts to timeout. But it warns you first. With this:


I use Chrome and as soon as this thing comes up, I have to click OK or Cancel before I can do anything. In any tab. It takes me to this no matter what I'm doing. If I have another application on top, I can't even click on Chrome in the Windows Task Bar to bring Chrome to the front because answering this question takes precedence. I even had trouble maximizing a minimized Chrome because of this horrible dialog box.

If you have let your healthcare.gov session sit for 25 minutes unused in a tab in Chrome, you've probably encountered this, too.

Starting Over From Scratch: Success!!!!!

My previous post shows how I finally got to the end. The success is described there. I just wanted a blog post title that says I succeeded.

Now, I'm going to go look at my options.... I hope....

Starting Over From Scratch: Doing The Application

OK, I just made the second account, and it's time to take it for a spin. This time, I'll not toy with asking for financial assistance. That might be what things so mucked up the last time. This is going to follow the basic flow I described in the earlier post about one cycle. In this page, I'll just highlight differences and interesting tidbits of information.

But first, let me point out that the website is right now much more responsive. It does, in fact, get more responsive every day. That is a good thing. Like a traffic jam, it will eventually let people through and they won't need to access these choke points anymore.

The first screen is just some text and a check box. The second page is that page I despise with a white hot passion because it always defaults with my preferred address and phone number handled stupidly. I have one address and one phone number. I want them to leave the check box checked rather than uncheck it and copy the information into secondary alternate addresses and phone numbers.

Same with the email address. This was one of those times were I checked the "Use my email address" check box, and it populated the first email address box, and it complained about the second one being empty.

They asked me if I want to use the email address they know about, but still want me to confirm it... Grrr.... I am convinced that there are different servers with different versions of validation software. That's just bad. Anyway.... I'm happily going along when I get this:
Again, there is progress. This has an error message. Exception in calling Save Insurance Application data service. I just decide to click the green "Save & Continue" button and let the chips fall where they may.

I mentioned that I used to get a separate question about being an Pacific Islander or Alaskan or something. It must be this. I haven't seen this dialog box in a while, but up it popped.

OK, the Pacific Islander part was wrong. But this is the screen. If I have problems on this account, I wonder if I'll see this screen again... I get closer and closer to the furthest most point I've ever gotten.

There used to be 4 of these boxes I had to check. Now there are 2. I'm really beginning to think that my database entry was corrupted on the old account. It had stuff about Medicaid, but this one doesn't. I click Save & Continue. Then I get the electronic signature box. In my excitement, I noticed it was different from the electronic signature box from the old account. This is the old account one:

Notice how the text above the part with the electronic signature doesn't really look like something an attorney wrote? Well, the one I had to sign today did. It had all that I swear that this stuff is true and accurate and yadda yadda yadda. Much more appropriate for an electronic signature. It also didn't have the gray button, I believe. So I pressed whatever I needed to and waited......

And I FINALLY got results? How happy am I? I wrote the word "finally" in all caps which I detest! That's how happy I am!

OK, let's view. It turns out, that the View Eligibilty Result makes me download a PDF.

So I download it. My computer came with Nuance PDF viewer installed and I've never bothered to change it to Adobe, but Nuance chokes and shows me nothing more than a page with Health Insurance Marketplace header and footer and a blank page.

So, I installed Adobe Reader XI and that didn't choke. I see that I am eligible. I now know what the Dec 15 deadline I've hearing about it. Your insurance doesn't start right away--it starts on the first of the month if you enroll on or before the 15th of the previous month. Obviously, it doesn't start before 2014, but there is that lag, I suppose to deter people who think they can sign up online from their phone en route to the hospital.

But, the take away from this long post:

  1. If you have problems, create a new account and start over
  2. Blow through error messages like they never even appeared
  3. But don't listen to me if you want financial aid because I skipped all that